After a tough loss at BYU, Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr’s Heisman odds seemed all but gone before November even started.
Coming into the season as the odds-on favorite to win the award per FanDuel Sportsbook, Carr started the season well but had seemingly fallen too far behind other players to have a solid shot at the award.
However, the future is a beautiful thing because it is never truly set in stone.
Less than a month later, Carr briefly returned to being the front runner to be named college football’s best player after a master class against then No. 1 Miami.
Everything that had been left to doubt about Carr when the Irish left Provo, Utah was answered Saturday when the Irish beat the Hurricanes 31-24.
Carr completed 29 of his 40 pass attempts for 319 yards and 3 touchdowns under the lights in Notre Dame Stadium.
Irish Sports Daily’s Jamie Uyeyama called Carr’s game against Miami his best given the circumstances in his Rewatch Notes.
“Carr was probably a little tight to start, but Denbrock did a nice job of helping him settle in,” said Uyeyama. “Then when Carr did, he performed under pressure. He finished with a 89.3 QBR and zero turnover-worthy plays. He led Notre Dame down in a two-minute drill before the half and this time he finished it the right way.
“He’s had more precise games. He’s never had a better game given the circumstances.”
After the win, Carr was seen taking the win in, which Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman said was a product of his competitiveness as well as the result of the BYU loss.
“No, it's both, right? He is a competitor. He wants to win so bad, like we all do. But I almost think it's a reflection of him embracing the victory. Like it's okay to enjoy it, right? Like you work really hard. Don't just check this one off and say, just another victory. Like, man, that was a big one. And enjoy it. I wanted them all to enjoy, and I thought he enjoyed it.
“He can be himself and show his emotion, because we know Sunday's coming. That's the truth. When you wake up on Sunday, I said it to you guys Saturday night, when you wake up on Sunday, you have to move forward for the next opponent. I thought that was a reflection of him truly enjoying the moment of a lot of hard work.”
With three regular season games remaining for Notre Dame, Carr’s season totals stand at 67.6% completion percentage, 2168 yards, 21 passing touchdowns, 1 interception and 3 rushing touchdowns.
The upcoming opponents?
Versus Boston College (4-5), vs. No. 25 SMU (7-2) and at Syracuse (4-5).
Carr now has that big-time win with a big-time performance under his belt.
Now it’s all about taking advantage of the remaining games on the schedule and leaving no doubt that he is the best player in college football.
Looking around the country, the field has narrowed by this point in the season to the players most likely to compete with Carr for the Heisman.
First is Miami quarterback Darian Mensah, whom Carr outdueled on Saturday.
Mensah and Carr have been the two quarterbacks most consistently at the top of the Heisman odds for most of the season.
Mensah has completed 76.8% of his passes while throwing for 2694 yards, 28 touchdowns, 2 interceptions and adding 2 touchdowns on the ground.
The other player who has been at the top of Heisman conversations and sportsbooks for most of the season is Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith.
Smith is the current odds-on favorite, having posted 69 receptions for 1,200 yards and 14 touchdowns.
While I wouldn’t say these three are the only contenders, they are the guys who have consistently remained at or near the top of the sportsbooks for most of the season and, at this moment in time, look like near-locks to be invited to New York.
While team performance hasn’t spoiled Heisman runs in the past (Jayden Daniels won the Heisman on a team that finished 10-3) Smith is having to deal with poor team performance this season.
Ohio State has already dropped three games and are missing starting quarterback Julian Sayin for the remainder of the season.
That leads me to believe that Carr and Mensah’s performances over the next couple weeks will likely determine this Heisman race.
However, much like Smith, Mensah is missing his half of one of college football’s best passing duos as Miami wideout Malachi Toney will likely miss the rest of the regular season but should return as soon as the ACC Championship game.
The matchups for the Smith and Mensah this week are as follows:
- No. 20 Ohio State vs. Northwestern
- No. 7 Miami vs. Duke
It’s finally crunch time for the Heisman Trophy, and CJ Carr has put himself right back into the thick of this race.
As the Irish prepare to face off against Boston College on Saturday, Carr needs to keep playing the way he did against Miami to give himself the best chance to be named college football’s best player.
Want the latest scoop on Notre Dame Football and Recruiting? Become an ISD Premium Subscriber and never miss the inside information. Sign Up for ISD
