Notre Dame fans shouldn’t be too worried about making the College Football Playoff.
ISD’s friendly data scientist Kyle Langham has updated his model this week and it now has the Irish making the 12-team field in 98% of its 20,000 simulated seasons, up from 95% last week. One more hurdle cleared, one less game to survive, and the berth itself is now close to a formality.
The potential first-round bye is another story, though.
A week ago, Notre Dame landed a top-four seed and a first-round bye in 70% of simulations, and the #2 seed was its single most likely landing spot. This week, the bye number is 54%, barely better than a coin flip while the projected seed has slid from #2 to #4 and the average seed has drifted from 3.7 to 4.5.
Nothing about that drop is Notre Dame's fault. The Irish did the only thing in their control, beating Boston College 41-7, and the model still moved them backward. That is what a tightening field looks like.
The two numbers tell opposite stories, and both are true.
The Playoff number rose because the path shortened. Notre Dame is 9-1 with two regular-season games left, SMU on Saturday and Syracuse on Nov. 28. The model gives the Irish an 88% chance of finishing 11-1, the single most likely final record by a wide margin. Win those two and the Irish are in. That part of the path has always been clear.
The bye number fell because the teams Notre Dame needs to pass are not cooperating.
Georgia, Utah, Alabama and UCLA all won again, and the committee's top four did not move at all on Tuesday night. The bye has become less about what Notre Dame does and more about what somebody else fails to do.
Still, Langham's model projects Notre Dame as the #4 seed, a bye team, because it plays out the remaining chaos: conference championship games, the SEC's two-loss logjam, somebody slipping somewhere.
The actual committee, working only with what has happened so far, moved Notre Dame the other direction on Tuesday night, dropping the Irish to #6 with Texas jumping them on the strength of its 22-21 win at LSU.
"Notre Dame did all they could," College Football Playoff Selection Committee chair Hunter Yurachek said during Tuesday night's teleconference. "It wasn't anything that Notre Dame did. It was Texas having an impressive win at one of our top 25 teams in LSU. It really gave Texas the nod over Notre Dame.
"That's a significant strength of schedule for Texas compared to Notre Dame."
Notre Dame's final two opponents, SMU and Syracuse, are both unranked, and SMU just lost 49-7 to Wake Forest. There is no résumé win left on the Irish schedule. If the committee's standard is ranked wins, Notre Dame's case is finished, frozen at whatever it is today, while Texas, Alabama and Tennessee still have ranked opponents and conference championship possibilities in front of them.
For all the movement in the seeding, the number at the top hardly changed. Notre Dame's national championship odds in the model sit at 21.3%, down just a tick from 21.8% last week.
That is the model's way of saying the bye matters at the margins, but not at the core. A Notre Dame team good enough to be the projected #4 seed is still one of the two or three most likely champions in the country, whether its path runs through a bye or through a first-round home game at Notre Dame Stadium.
The bye is still worth wanting. Langham's own work values it at roughly five points of championship odds for a team like Notre Dame. But the season doesn’t necessarily hinge on it.
The math from here is simple, even if the Irish do not fully control it.
Win out, and Notre Dame is in the field, full stop and the only question left is seeding.
For the bye, the Irish need help, and they need it from a short list: a loss by two of Georgia, Utah, Alabama, UCLA and Texas, or championship-weekend chaos that scrambles the top of the bracket.
The SEC is the most likely source. Alabama, Texas and Tennessee are all 8-2, crowded behind Georgia, and at least one of them has to lose ground before this is over. But even that may not be enough depending on which team loses and to who.
For now, the math and the committee agree on the essential point, even if they disagree on the seed.
Want the latest scoop on Notre Dame Football and Recruiting? Become an ISD Premium Subscriber and never miss the inside information. Sign Up for ISD