Notre Dame Basketball

Notre Dame's Offense Explodes in Overtime Win Over Rutgers

Brady Koehler and Braeden Smith combined for 53 points on 18-of-22 shooting as Notre Dame outlasted Rutgers in overtime.
November 18, 2026
606 Views
Discuss
Story Poster
Photo by Keira Jones | ISD

Defense was optional in Las Vegas on Wednesday afternoon as Notre Dame (5-1) and Rutgers (3-2) faced off for the third time in three years at the Players Era Tournament.

Notre Dame forward Brady Koehler scored 27 points and Braeden Smith added 26 on near-perfect shooting as the Fighting Irish shook off a 7-0 Rutgers run to close regulation and pulled away for a 110-100 overtime victory.

Notre Dame dominated the extra period, outscoring the Scarlet Knights 15-5.

The Irish finally locked down defensively in overtime, holding Rutgers to 2-of-13 shooting from the field and 0-of-4 from beyond the arc. Notre Dame also went a perfect 10-for-10 from the free-throw line to seal the win.

Notre Dame shot 65 percent from the field for the game, while Rutgers wasn't far behind at 54 percent.

Koehler was sensational from start to finish, finishing 8-of-11 from the field and 4-of-4 from three-point range. He also added a team-high eight rebounds, five assists, two blocks and zero turnovers. Smith was just as efficient, going 10-of-11 from the floor with six rebounds and six assists.

But it wasn't just Koehler and Smith stepping up for Micah Shrewsberry. All five starters reached double figures as Ethan Roberts scored 17 points, Braeden Shrewsberry chipped in 13 and Logan Duncomb added 12 before fouling out with 1:36 remaining in regulation.

Tariq Francis led Rutgers with 25 points, four assists and three steals, while Lino Mark posted 23 points, eight rebounds and six assists. Jamichael Davis scored 14 points off the bench, and big man Christian Gurdak recorded a double-double with 13 points and 10 rebounds.

HOLY MOLY
Koehler and Smith were about as efficient as two players can be in a basketball game. Four combined misses on 22 field-goal attempts will work just fine.

Notre Dame went 12 minutes between misses, connecting on 15 consecutive field goals in the first half to build a double-digit lead.

The Irish nearly duplicated that stretch in the second half, hitting 12 straight field goals to push their advantage to 95-88 before Rutgers mounted its frantic 7-0 run in just 45 seconds.

That efficiency starts with ball movement. Notre Dame recorded 21 assists on 40 made field goals, continuing its trend of sharing the basketball rather than relying on isolation possessions.

Shrewsberry has sets that get players open and the shots are being knocked it. It’s what was expected coming off an NCAA Tournament run during his final year at Penn State. 

The Irish also continued their hot shooting from three-point range, going 11-of-23 for the game. Koehler, Shrewsberry and Roberts combined for 10 of those makes.

The bench, however, remains a concern.

Notre Dame received 15 points from its reserves, led by Logan Imes, who scored nine points in 21 minutes. The only other bench players to score were Bryce Ruglass Dortch (four points) and Gan-Erdene Solongo (two points).

CLEAN UPAs impressive as the offense was Wednesday, Notre Dame's defense was downright poor at times.

Transitions on defense and mental errors plagued the Irish throughout the afternoon, allowing Rutgers to hang around in a game Notre Dame had seemingly taken control of multiple times.

The Irish were outscored 14-3 in second-chance points while allowing Rutgers to grab 11 offensive rebounds. That's an area that must improve moving forward, especially with ACC play approaching.

Notre Dame’s lack of athleticism and size does show itself at times. But the X-factor is Koehler, as he can protect the rim and rebound. The loss of Tommy Ahnen is significant, as Duncomb is a bit limited when facing an athletic big. 

This game was ultimately about offense, and Notre Dame made the necessary defensive stops in overtime. However, allowing a 7-0 run in the final 45 seconds of regulation is something this team cannot afford if it wants to make a statement this season.

That said, Notre Dame's experience showed up when it mattered most.

There was no panic when adversity hit, and multiple players were ready to step up and take big shots. That's a noticeable difference from years past, when it often seemed like only one or two players were prepared for those moments.

UP NEXT
Notre Dame will play the winner of Auburn-UNLV on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET on ESPN. 

Want the latest scoop on Notre Dame Football and Recruiting? Become an ISD Premium Subscriber and never miss the inside information. Sign Up for ISD

Discuss
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.